Titansteel Destroyer vs Colossal Skull-Clad Cleaver

[Rúne]

Ok, I'm back from a 2 month break from WoW...and now I can Dual Spec...

I'm Blood for DPS and Frost for Tanking. I have really good pre-Naxx tank gear, and ok pre-naxx dps gear. My plan is to put Rune of the Fallen Crusader on my DPS weapon, and Rune of Swordshattering on my tanking weapon.

I can get two of both Titansteel Destroyer and Colosal Skull-Clad Cleaver.

so my question is which should I use for what? Tank with Destroyer or Cleaver, and DPS with Destroyer or Cleaver? If I should tank and DPS with the same weapon, I plan to get two of that weapon so I don't have to keep re-Runeforging my item.

Any suggestions?

[Ash]

I would go with the destroyer for both. Definitely for tanking, might be more of a personal preference issue for DPS.

There aren't any wasted stats on the Destroyer unless your tank gear is hit capped. (not very common)

For tanking, especially, haste is a poor stat. I tend to value it very low for dps as well, primarily since it's so common on the rest of our gear.

[Akar]

Option 3:

Argent Tournament Sword - 25 tokens easy enough to get.